Avicennian Types of Gradation: From Priority and Posteriority to Firmness and Weakness

Document Type : Scholarly Article

Author
Department of Islamic Philosophy and Theology, Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad.
10.30497/ap.2026.251037.1808
Abstract
At the beginning of the Logic of The Healing (al-Shifāʾ), Avicenna classifies absolute gradational terms (al-alfāẓ al-mushakkika al-muṭlaqa) into three types: gradation through priority and posteriority (taqaddum wa-taʾakhkhur), gradation through worthiness (awlawiyya), and gradation through intensity and weakness (shidda wa-ḍaʿf). Elsewhere in his works, he addresses these types and related discussions in a scattered manner, or employs similar terminology. In examining these discussions, the central question of this study is whether Avicenna remained faithful to the aforementioned threefold classification throughout all of his works. Several subsidiary questions follow from this central question, including: Which of the types of priority and posteriority is relevant to gradation in terms of priority and posteriority? Why are increase and decrease in quantities not regarded as instances of gradation? Is firmness and weakness (taʾakkud wa-taḍaʿʿuf) a new type of gradation?

This study demonstrates that Avicenna consistently adheres to the aforementioned threefold classification. Gradation in terms of priority and posteriority can be discussed only with respect to natural and causal priority and posteriority. Gradation in terms of worthiness (awlawiyya) is broader in scope than gradation in terms of priority and posteriority. Differences with respect to truth, necessity and possibility, independence and need, as well as differences with respect to firmness and weakness (taʾakkud wa-taḍaʿʿuf), can all be reduced to gradation through worthiness (awlawiyya). In Avicenna, firmness and weakness (taʾakkud wa-taḍaʿʿuf) are not identical with intensity and weakness (shidda wa-ḍaʿf), nor do they constitute a new type of gradation. No quantity is characterized by increase and decrease in terms of its nature and essence; consequently, increase and decrease in quantities are not included among the types of gradation
Keywords
Subjects


Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 21 November 2026