Al-Farabi and Ibn Sina on the Relationship between Philosophy and Jurisprudence in the Classification of Sciences

Document Type : Scholarly Article

Author

Associate Professor of Islamic Philosophy, Research Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies.Tehran,Iran.

Abstract

The classification of sciences is a fundamental topic in epistemology and has a significant impact on determining the position, role, and function of each branch of knowledge. Considering the centrality of wisdom (ḥikmah) and Islamic law (shariʿah) in Islamic thought, the classification of sciences has sometimes been structured around these two principles. This paper investigates the relationship between philosophy and jurisprudence, or ḥikmah and shariʿah, as articulated in the classification systems of Al-Farabi and Ibn Sina. It examines the foundations, implications, and consequences of their approaches within their respective philosophical frameworks. The research employs a descriptive-analytical methodology. The findings reveal that both philosophers acknowledge the compatibility of philosophy and religion, but their prioritizations differ. Al-Farabi prioritizes philosophy, placing jurisprudence and theology under practical wisdom, which is subordinate to theoretical wisdom. In contrast, Ibn Sina prioritizes religion, considering shariʿah as an independent science within practical wisdom, distinct from human sciences and with a divine origin. Ibn Sina views shariʿah as an independent science alongside political science, not as a branch of it. By granting shariʿah an independent identity, Ibn Sina lends it credibility and creates conditions for its potential substitution for practical wisdom in the trajectory of Islamic philosophy. He lays the groundwork for the two sciences of usul al-din (theology) and furuʿ al-din (jurisprudence). It appears that Ibn Sina perceives the realization of philosophy in the Islamic society of his time in the Islamization of philosophy and the validation of religious sciences. Therefore, compared to Al-Farabi, Ibn Sina is more concerned with the Islamization of philosophy and seeks to harmonize the philosophy of his predecessors with his own society.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1. Books

    1. Āmoli, Sayyed Haidar (1386). Jami-al-Asrar, proofreader: Henry Karban and Osman Yahya, Tehran, Scientific and Cultural Publications. [Arabic]
    2. . Ibn Sina, Hossein bin Abdullah (1363). AL-SHIFA.Al- Ilahiyyat. Edited by Dr. Ebrahim, Madkour Tehran: Nasser Khosro Publications. [Arabic]
    3. . Ibn Sina, Hossein bin Abdullah (1375). Madkhale Mantiq SHIFA. Edited and referenced by Dr. Ebrahim Madkour, researched by Dr. Abul Ala Afifi, Cairo, Al-Mattaba Al-Amiriyya. [Arabic]
    4. . Ibn Sina, Hossein bin Abdullah (1908). A collection of treatises. Edited by Amin Handiyeh, Egypt: Balmoski Indian Press. [Arabic]
    5. . Ibn Sina, Hossein bin Abdullah (2017). Mantiq al- Mshreqiin, Hindawi, America. [Arabic]
    6. . Ibn Sina, Hossein bin Abdullah (1315). Danishnama-yi ‘Alã’i. Proofreading by Ahmad Khorasani, Tehran: Central Printing House.
    7. . Bekar, Osman (1369). Classification of sciences according to Muslim sages. Translated by Javad Ghasemi, Mashhad: Astan Quds Razavi Foundation Research. [ Persian]
    8. . Shirazi, Qutb al-Din (Allamah Mahmoud bin Masoud Kazrooni) (1369) Durra al-Taj Laghara al-Dabaj. Tehran: Hekmat Publications.
    9. . Khwarazmi, Muhammad ibn Ahmad (1428). Mofatihul Uloom. Beirut: Dar al-Manahel. [Arabic]
    10. . Davari Ardakani, Reza (2536). The position of philosophy in the history of the Islamic period of Iran. Tehran: Bureau of Planning and Cultural Studies. .[ Persian]
    11. . Zabihi, Muhammad (1397). Practical wisdom from the perspective of three Muslim philosophers: Farabi, Ibn Sina and Mulla Sadra. Tehran: Side.
    12. Tusi, Nasir al-Din (1356). Naseri ethics. Edited by Mojtaba Minavi, Tehran: Bina. [ Persian]
    13. Tusi, Nasir al-Din (1359). Summary of Al-Massal known as Naqd al-Massal. Edited by: Abdullah Noorani, Tehran: University of Tehran and McGill Institute of Islamic Studies. [Arabic]
    14. . Ameri, Abulhasan Mohammad (1367). Al-Alam Bamnaqib Islam. Tehran: Bina.
    15. . Arafa Mansia, Moqdad (2013). Al-Farabi: Philosophy of religion and Islamic sciences. Tunisia: Darul Madar al-Islami[Arabic]
    16. .. Fārābī, Muḥammad b. Muḥammad. (2002). Al-Siyāsat al-madaniyya. Edited by Ali Bu Mulham. Beirut: Maktabat al-Hilal.[Arabic]
    17. . Fārābī,. Muhammad bin Muhammad (1381). Ihsā al-‘Ulum Translated by Hossein Khadivjam, Ch3, Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publications. [Arabic]
    18. Fārābī, Muḥammad b. Muḥammad.( 1969). Al-Ḥurūf. Edited by Muhsin Mahdi. Beirut:Dar al-Mashriq. [Arabic]
    19. Fārābī,. Muhammad bin Muhammad (1408). Al- Manteqiiat, Mohammad Taghi Daneshpajoh, Volume 1, Qom: Marashi Library. [Arabic]
    20. Fārābī,. Muhammad bin Muhammad (1992). Al-Tanbih ala Sabil al-saʿāda. Research by Jafar Al-Yasin, Beirut, Dar al-Manahel. [Arabic]
    21. Fārābī, Muḥammad b. Muḥammad.( 2001). Kitāb al-milla wa-nuṣūṣ ukhrā. Edited byMuhsin Mahdi. Beirut: Dar al-Mashriq.. [Arabic]
    22. Fārābī,. Muhammad bin Muhammad (1353). Plato's philosophy and parts. In addition to the book of Plato in Islam Abdur Rahman Badavi, Tehran. [Arabic]
    23. Al-Kindi,A.Y(1950).Rasa’il al-kindi al Falsafiyah , ed .A.Abu Rida, Cairo,Dar Al - Fekr AL- Arabi [Arabic]
    24. Neton, Ian Richard (2017). Farabi and his school. Translated by Golbaba Saeedi, Tehran: Museum of Islamic Council Documents. [ Persian]

    25- Bertolacci .Amos (2011),”On the Latin Reception of Avicenna’s Metaphysics before Albertus Magnus: An Attempt at Periodization” From the book The Arabic, Hebrew and Latin Reception of Avicenna's Metaphysics, Dag Nikolaus Hasse & Amos Bertolacci (eds.). De Gruyter, Universität Würzburg, Germany, pp. 197-224.

    26- Gutas. Dimitri, ( 2002), “The Heritage of Avicenna: The Golden Age of Arabic Philosophy, 1000 ‑ ca. 1350,” ,Avicenna and his Heritage, Edited by Janssens and Daniel de smet, Leuven University Press . pages 81-97.

    27- Gutas. Dimitri, ( 2016) “Historical and social approaches to philosophy. Avicenna and after : the development of paraphilosophy : a history of science approach”, Islamic philosophy from the 12th to the 14th century. Bonn University Press .

     

    28- Goichon. A. M.(1969). "The Philosophy of Avicenna and its Influence on Medieval Europe "Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass

    • D.N (2008),"Influence of Arabic and Islamic Philosophy on theLatin west", Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

    30 - Fakhry Majid (2002), AL-Farabi, Founder of Islamic Neoplatonism, ONEWORLD, OXFORD.

    31- Bouhafa  Feriel (2019), “Ethics and Fiqh in al-Fārābī’sPhilosophy”, Philosophy in the Islamic Worl d in Context, Edited by Peter Adamson, De Gruyter.p: 11-29.

     

     

    1. B) Articles:

    32= Asadi, Mohammadreza, Badrkhani, Gholamreza (1397). "Practical wisdom in Sinavi philosophy; its position, foundations and causes of its decline" Hekmat Sinavi magazine, No. 60, pp. 27-45. [ Persian]

    33- Bouzerinejad, Yahya and Qasim Khosravi (1393), "The place of human knowledge in the classification of sciences from the point of view of Farabi, Ghazali and Khwaja Nasir Toosi", Scientific Quarterly of Social Theories of Muslim Thinkers, Vol. 6, pp. 169-191. [ Persian]

    34-. Sharifi, Hessamuddin et al. (1397). "Place and methodology of practical wisdom from Farabi's point of view", Hikmat Islamic magazine, pp. 124-105.

    • . Davari, Reza (1348). "Proposing issues related to the transfer of Greek philosophy to the Islamic world and the influence of Plato and Aristotle on Farabi's practical wisdom", Islamic Education Magazine, Awqaf Organization, No. 8, pp. 106-112. [ Persian]
    • . Dolpazri, Javad (2019) "What is practical wisdom and its place in the classification of sciences", Islamic Hikmat magazine, pp. 121-140. [ Persian]
    • . Qanadinejad, Farzaneh and Heydari, Gholamreza (1398). "Classification of sciences from the point of view of scholars of the Islamic era from the second century of Hijri to the present era", Library Studies and Information Organization, Vol. 118, pp. 17-2. [ Persian]
    • . Karamati, Yunus (1387); "The influence of Farabi's views on the classification of sciences in Europe in the middle centuries", Kitabmah al-Falshaf, No. 17. [ Persian]
    • . Kadivar, Mohsen (1387). "Avicenna and the classification of wisdom". Javidan Khord magazine, pp. 35-39. [ Persian]
    • . Mostaqimi, Mahdia Sadat (1387) "An applied study of Ibn Sina's theory about the classification of sciences", Philosophical-Theological Researches, No.: 1 (37) pp. 175-198. [ Persian]
    • . . Nikosfat Rad, Ahmed and Mohammad Saidi Mehr (1390). "Civic philosophy and civic science: a look at Farabi's practical wisdom". Journal of Ethical Research, No. 4. [ Persian]

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics