Conceptual Metaphors of ‘Knowledge by Presence’ in Avicennian Philosophy

Mobaraki, Fatemeh; Alavi, Seyed Mohammad Kazem; Ershadinia, Mohammadreza

doi:10.30497/ap.2024.245302.1648

Conceptual Metaphors of ‘Knowledge by Presence’ in Avicennian Philosophy

Document Type : Scholarly Article

Authors

¹ Phd Student in Islamic Philosophy and Theology, Sabzevar Branch, Islamic Azad University, Sabzevar, Iran.

² Associate Professor of Islamic Philosophy and Wisdom, Hakim Sabzevari University, Sabzevar, Iran.

10.30497/ap.2024.245302.1648

Abstract

Contemporary theories in cognitive semantics suggest that humans utilize conceptual metaphors, either consciously or subconsciously, to distill complex mental constructs into simpler forms. Philosophers, in particular, have extensively employed conceptual metaphors to render abstract philosophical notions comprehensible. This study delves into the application of conceptual metaphors in elucidating ‘knowledge by presence’ within Avicenna’s philosophy. Ibn Sinā employed these metaphors to articulate and streamline the concept of ‘knowledge by presence.’ He posits that such knowledge is actualized when the object of knowledge is directly present to the knower, that is, the soul. However, he asserts that mere presence is not the sole requisite for attaining knowledge; rather, conditions conducive to vision and illumination must also be met for presence to culminate in knowledge acquisition. Interpreting his discourse yields two metaphors: ‘knowledge by presence as seeing’ and ‘knowledge by presence as illumination.’ The ‘seeing’ metaphor hinges on three critical elements: the observer, the observed, and their interrelation. Conversely, the ‘illumination’ metaphor involves two key elements: the source of illumination and the object being illuminated. This article endeavors to explore the conceptual metaphors associated with ‘knowledge by presence’ in Avicennian philosophy through an exploratory approach, deliberately eschewing any hypothesis formulation.

Keywords

Main Subjects

Philosophy of mysh

References

The Holy Quran. [In Persian]

- Ibn Sinā, Hossein bin Abdullāh (1933). Me’rājnāmeh. Qom: Urwat al-Wothqā Press. [In Persian]

- Ibn Sinā, Hussein bin Abdullah (1978). Al-Insāf. Kuwait: Wikālat al-Matbu’āt. [In Persian]

- Ibn Sinā, Hossein bin Abdullāh (1979). Avicenna's Epistles. Qom: Bīdār. [In Persian]- Ibn Sinā, Hussein bin Abdullāh (1983 a). Al-Ta’līghāt. Qom: Maktab al-I’lām al-Islāmiyat. [In Persian]-Ibn Sinā, Hossein bin Abdullāh (1983 b) Al-Shifā, al-Ilāhiyāt. Qom: Mar’ashī Najafī. [In Persian] - Ibn Sinā, Hussein bin Abdullāh (1983 c). Al-Shifā, al-Mantiq. Qom: Mar’ashī Najafī. [In Persian]- Ibn Sinā, Hussein bin Abdullāh (1984). Al- Mabda wa al-Ma’ād. Tehran: Institute of Islamic Studies. [In Persian]- Ibn Sinā, Hussein bin Abdullāh (1992). Al Mobāhethat. Qom: Bīdār. [In Persian]

- Ibn Sinā, Hussein bin Abdullāh (1996). Al-Ishārāt wa al-Tanbīhāt. Qom: Nashr al-Balāghat. CD Kitabkhaneh Hikmat. Noorsoft. [In Persian]

- Ibn Sinā, Hussein bin Abdullāh (2003). Al-uzhawiyah fi al-Al-Ma’ād. Tehran: Shams Tabrīzī. [In Persian]- Ibn Sinā, Hussein bin Abdullāh (2004 a). Five Treatises (by effort: Ihsān Yarshāter). Hamedān: Bu Ali Sinā University. [In Persian]- Ibn Sinā, Hussein bin Abdullāh (2004 b). Risālah Nafs. Hamedan: Hamedān: Bu Ali Sinā University.[In Persian]- Ibn Sinā, Hossein bin Abdullāh (2017). Nafs Shifā. (translator: Mohammed Hossein Naeijī). Qom: Imam Khomeinī Educational and Research Institute. [In Persian]- Beheshti, Ahmad. (1992). Tajrīd Sharh Namat Haftom Al-Ishārāt wa al-Tanbīhāt. Qom: Bustan Kitab. [In Persian]

- Khadimzādeh, Vahīd: )2014). Metaphor of Existence as Light in Mulla Sadra's Philosophy. Islamic Philosophy and Kalam, 49(1), pp. 19-34. [In Persian]

- Khadimzādeh, Vahīd (2016). The Metaphor of a Real Being as a Fixed Thing According to Ibn Sinā and Mullā Sadrā. Contemporary Wisdom, 8(3), pp. 51-21. [In Persian]- Khadimzādeh, Vahīd: (2021). Investigating the Statistical Analysis of Conceptual Metaphors of Causality in Healing Theology. Linguistic Essays, 12(1), pp. 365-397. [In Persian]- Khadimzādeh, Vahīd and Fātimeh Kanani. (2022). The Conceptual Metaphor of "Knowing As Seeing" In Mullā Sadrā's Philosophical System. Contemporary Wisdom. 13(34), pp. 29-61. [In Persian]- Khadimzādeh, Vahīd (2023). Conceptual Metaphors Based on the Subject-Face Direction in Mullā Sadrā's Philosophy. Mind Scientific Journal, 24(93), pp. 102-129. . [In Persian]- Zargoushī, Zainab (2019). The Use of Metaphor in Suhrawardī's Epistemology. Islamic Philosophy and Theology, 61-81. [In Persian]- Abbāsī, Zahrī; Amin Khosravī (2018). Analyzing the Metaphorical Mappings of the Concept of Death in Molavi's Works. Literary Research Quarterly, 16(63), pp. 117-89. [In Persian]-Fārābī, Muhammad bin Muhammad (1984). Fosūs al-Hikam. Qom: Bīdār. [In Persian]- Ghāemīniā, Alirezā (2011). Cognitive Semantics of the Qur'ān. Tehran: Islamic Culture and Thought Research Institute Publishing Organization.

- Ghāemīniā, Alirezā (2016). Conceptual Metaphors and Spaces of the Qurān. Tehran: Islamic Culture and Thought Research Institute Publishing Organization. [In Persian]

- Lakoff, George & Mark Johnson (1980). Metaphors we Live By. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.

- Lakoff, George (1993). The contemporary Theory of Metaphor and Thought In: Andrew Ortony (ed.), Metaphor and Thought. Cambridge University Press. pp. 202-251.

- Momenī ‘Ali and Mansour Imānpour (2019). Conceptual Metaphor and the Problem of Excess of Existence Over Essence in Islamic Philosophy. Hikmat Sinavī. 24(63), pp. 219-235. [In Persian]

- Nasīr al-Din Tūsi, Muhammad bin Muhammad (1996). Sharh Al-Ishārāt wa al-Tanbīhāt. Qom: Nashr al-Balāghat. [In Persian]