Sensory Perception and Its Philosophical Foundations in Avicenna and Leibniz

Document Type : Scholarly Article

Author

Associate Professor at the Department of Philosophy, Payam Noor University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

Due to its crucial role in acquiring knowledge, sense perception and its philosophical foundations have consistently been among the major topics in the history of philosophy. Avicenna, as a peripatetic (Aristotelian) Muslim philosopher, dedicated special attention to this problem. He advocated the unity of the soul despite the separation and multiplicity of the soul’s functional powers, leading him to posit an interaction or correlation between sensory and intellectual faculties. In the modern era, characterized by an emphasis on reason (intellect) and a perceived separation between reason and experience, Leibniz took a different approach. Drawing on his extensive knowledge of scholastic and ancient philosophers, he sought to reconcile elements of both old and new philosophies in forming his metaphysics. He based his metaphysical framework on select principles from Aristotelian logic but developed a unique theory regarding the unity of sensory and rational faculties. This paper aims to examine and compare these two philosophical viewpoints. Both philosophers held that it is impossible to fully grasp the truth of sensible objects, as knowledge is limited to understanding the properties and accidents of objects rather than their true nature. However, they diverged in their philosophical thinking, rooted in their respective worldviews and their stances on unity and plurality. Consequently, they both acknowledged the necessity of sense perception and the experimental method in acquiring knowledge, while simultaneously emphasizing the importance of reason and rational methods.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Ahmadi, Ahmed (1388). The foundations of knowledge. Tehran: samt
-Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah (1363). Al-Mabad and Al-Ma'ad (1st print). Tehran: Institute of Islamic Studies.
-Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah (1371). Al-Mobahesat (Mohsen Bidarfar, introduction writer and investigate(researcher)) (1st print). Qom: Bidar.
-Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah (1375). AL-Esharat and Al-Tanbihat (1st print). Qom: publisher al-Balagha.
-Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah (1379). Al-Najat Man Al-Gharq Fi Bahr Al-Zilala) (Mohammed Taghi, Daneshpaguh, introduction wtiter and the corrector) (2nd print). Tehran: University of Tehran.
-Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah (1383). Al-Adhawiya fi al-Maad (Hasan Asi, investigate). Tehran: Shams Tabrizi.
-Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah (1404 A). Al-Taliqat (Abd al-Rahman Badawi, investigate). Qom: Mactabat Al-Aalam Islamic.
-Avicenna, Hossein bin Abdullah (1404 B). Al-Shifa: Theology (Saeed Zaid and Abb Qanawati, correctors). Qom: Ayatollah Murashi Najafi Library.
-Avicenna, Hossein bin Abdullah (1404 c). Al-Shifa: physics (3volume) (2nd perint). Qom: Ayatollah Murashi Najafi Library.
-Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah (1405 A). Al-Shifa: Matiq. Qom: Ayatollah Murashi Najafi Library.
-Avicenna, Hossein bin Abdullah (1405 B). Logic of the Orientals (2nd print). Qom: Ayatollah Murashi Najafi Library.
-Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah (1989). Al-Hudoud (print 2). Cairo: The Egyptian General Book Authority.
-Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah (2007). Ahwal al-Nafs: Risalat fi-nafs va Baqaoha va Maadeha (Fouad Al-Ahwani, introduction writer). Paris: Dar Biblioen.
- Beiser, Frederick C. (2009) Diotima's Children: German Aesthetic Rationalism from Leibniz to Lessing, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
 
-Capleston, Frederick Charles (1386). History of Philosophy (Gholamreza Awani, translator) (Volume 4) (Print 3). Tehran: Scientific and Cultural.
-Ebrahimi Dinani, Gholamhossein (1392). Avicenna’s speech and Bahmanyar's explanation (1st print). Tehran: Iranian Wisdom and Philosophy Research Institute.
- Foroughi, Mohammad Ali (1367). Thegarlic(current) of philosophy in Europe (2nd edition). Tehran: Zovar.
- Hammermeister, Kai (2002) The German Aesthetic Tradition, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
-Hasanzadeh Amoli, Hassan (1386). Description of Avicenna's Esharat va Tabihat: the third chapter (Volume 1). Qom: Ayat Ashraq.
-Hassanzadeh Amoli, Hassan (1417). Al-Nafs Man Kitab al-Shifa (print 1) Qom:Mactabat Al-Mahad Al-Islami School, Al-Nashar Center.
-Karaba, Jameel (2015). Philosophical culture (Manochehar Saneyi Darhabidi, translator) (1st edition). Tehran: Hikmat.
-Lata, Robert (1384). Leibniz's philosophy (Fateme Minaei, translator). Tehran: Hermes.
-Leibnitz, Gottfried Wilhelm (1372). Monadology and some other articles (Abdulkarim Rashidian, translator) (1st print). Tehran, Publications and Education of the Islamic Revolution.
-Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm (1375). Monadology (Buter and others, introduction writers and commentators) (Yahi Mahdavi, translator) (1st print). Tehran: Kharazmi.
-Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm (1381). Speech in metaphysics (Ibrahim Dadjo, translator). Tehran: Hikmat.
-Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm (1983). New research in human understanding, epistemology (Ahmed Fouad Kamel, translator and researcher). Maghreb: House of culture for publication and distribution
 
-Mojtahedi, Karim (1373). A look at new and contemporary philosophies in the Western world (1st print). Tehran: Amir Kabir.
-Momeni, Mustafa (1397). The concept of nature and the negation of natural perceptions in Avicenna thought. Javidankhard,N: 34, P: 161-178.
-Mirzaei, Dawood; Mirzaei, Ali; and Mahouzi, Reza (1397). The relationship between sensory perception and aesthetic and aesthetic experience in Leibniz's aesthetics. Tabriz University Philosophical Investigations Magazine, N;12(23), p: 178-194.
-Nasr, Seyyed Hossein (1345). The opinion of Islamic thinkers about nature (2nd print). Tehran: Dehkhoda.
-Nasr, Seyyed Hossein (1384). Three Muslim sages (Ahmed Aram, translator) (6th print). Tehran: Scientific and Cultural.
-Nasir al-Din Tusi, Muhammad bin Muhammad (1375). Description of Avicenna's Esharat va tanbihat (Third chapter) (Volume 2) (Print 1). Qom: El Balagha.
-Nasir al-Din Tusi, Muhammad bin Muhammad (1383). Answers to Al-Masail al-Nusriyyah (Abdullah Noorani, with effort). Tehran: Research Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies.
-Nicholas, Jali (1391). Leibniz (Sayed Masoud Hosseini Tushmanloui, translator). Tehran: Qoqnoos.
-Omid, Masoud (2008). Rereading Avicenna's theory of the nature of perception. Khradname Sadra, N: 57, p: 33-41.
-Russell, Bertrand (1384). A critical description of Leibniz's philosophy (In addition to the highlights) (Iraj Kouni, translator) (2nd print). Tehran: Ney Publishers.
-Sanei Darhabidi, Manouchehr (1383). Leibniz's philosophy. Tehran: Qoqnoos.
-Tahanwi, Muhammad Ali bin Ali (1996). Kashsaf Iztalahat al-Funun va Al- Uloom (1st print). Beirut: Lebanese library Publishers.
-Thomas, Henry (1365). Philosophers (Feridon Badrhai, translator). Tehran: Kahan-Scientific and Cultural.
Avecinnian Philosophy Journal
Volume 26, Issue 68
October 2022
Pages 25-50

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics