Avicenna’s Arguments against Metempsychosis

Document Type : Scholarly Article

Author

PhD of Contemporary philosophy, Tehran University, College of Farabi, Qom, Iran.

Abstract

Metempsychosis is the concept of the transmigration of a human or animal soul into another human, animal, plant, or even an inanimate object. The theory of metempsychosis poses a challenge to the belief in resurrection (Maʿād), making it necessary to reject metempsychosis before proving Maʿād. Avicenna presents two arguments against metempsychosis. The first argument, found in numerous works, rejects metempsychosis on the grounds that it requires the union of two souls within a single body. Avicenna alludes to the second argument in his Al-Isharat wa al-Tanbihat but postpones its full explanation to another unspecified work. Nasir al-Din al-Tusi, Fakhr al-Din Razi, and Qutb al-Din Razi have proposed different interpretations of this second argument. The variations in interpretation revolve around the number of implications Avicenna expressed for this modus ponendo and his reasons for rejecting them. Among these interpretations, only Qutb al-Din Razi's aligns more closely with Avicenna's original words. In the other two interpretations, there are either deficiencies or excesses compared to Avicenna's work.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Ibn Babawayh al-Qummi, Muhammad ibn 'Ali (1378 AH). Uyun akhbar al-Rida (the springs of the narrations of al-Rida) (Mahdi Lajordi, researcher and proofreader) (Volume 2) (Print 1). Tehran: Nashr Jahan.
Ibn Sīnā, Hussein bin Abdullah (1363). Al-Mabda' wa al-ma'ad (1st edition). Tehran: Institute of Islamic Studies.
Ibn Sīnā, Hussein bin Abdullah (1379). Al-Najat Man Al-Gharq Fi Bahr Al-Dilalat (Mohammed Taqi scholar, introduction and proofreader) (2nd edition). Tehran: University of Tehran.
Ibn Sīnā, Hussein bin Abdullah (1382). Al-Risala al-'adhawiyya fi 'amr al-ma'ad (Hasan Asi, researcher) (1st edition). Tehran: Shams Tabrizi.
Ibn Sīnā, Hussein bin Abdullah (1383). Risalah al-nafs (Mousa Omid, introduction writer, annotator and proofreader) (2nd edition). Hamedan: Bu Ali Sina University.
Ibn Sīnā, Hussein bin Abdullah (1387). Al-'Isharat wa al-Tanbihat (Mojtabi Zarei, Mohaghegh) (2nd edition). Qom: Bostan Kitab.
Ibn Sīnā, Hussein bin Abdullah (1404 AH). Al-Ta'liqat (Abd al-Rahman al-Badwi, researcher). Beirut: School of Islamic Media.
Ibn Sīnā, Hossein bin Abdullah (1404 BC). Al-Shifa': Theology (Said Zayed, revised). Qom: Ayatollah Al-Marashi Library.
Ibn Sīnā, Hussein bin Abdullah (1417 AH). Al-Nafs Man Kitab al-Shifa (Hasan Hassanzadeh Amoli, Mohaghegh) (1st edition) Qom: School of Islamic Media.
Ibn Sina, Hussein bin Abdullah (2007). Ahwal al-Nafs: Risalat fi-nafs and its survival and revivals (Fouad Al-Ahwani, introduction writer and scholar). Paris: Dar Biblion.
Hassanzadeh Amoli, Hassan (1365). Hizar-o-yik nukta (5th edition). Tehran: Please.
Hassanzadeh Amoli, Hassan (1385). Uyun masaele al-nafs va sarh al-Uyun fi sharh al-Uyun (2nd edition). Tehran: Amir Kabir.
Hosseini Zubeidi, Mohammad Morteza (1414 AH). Taj al-Arus Man Javaher al-Qamoos (Ali Shiri, researcher and proofreader) (1st edition) Beirut: Dar al-Fakr.
Khansari, Agha Hossein (1388). Al-Hashiya ʿalā shoruh al-isharat: Al-Isharat and Shahrah al-Isharat and Shahrah al-Sharh and Hashiya al-Baghnavi (Ahmad Abedi, Mohagheg) (Volume 2) (2nd edition) Qom: Bostan Kitab.
Al-Rāzī, Fakhr al-dīn Muhammad bin Omar (1404 AH). Sharh al-Fakhr al-Razi ʿalā al-Isharat (Sharh al-Isharat) (volume 2). Qom: School of Ayatollah al-Marashi.
Sabzivārī, Hādī Ibn Mahdī (1379-1369). Sharḥ al-Manẓūmā (Hasan Hasanzadeh Amoli, proofreader and annotator) (Volumes 2 and 5) (1st edition). Tehran: Nab Publishing.
Suzanchi, Hossein (1379). Theory of transmogrification 1: Introduction and History. Islamic Education Quarterly, 11(41)/, 30-36.
Shīrāzī, Ṣadr al-Dīn Muḥammad (1354). Al-Mabda' wa al-ma'ad (Seyd Jalaluddin Ashtiani, revised). Tehran: Iranian Wisdom and Philosophy Association.
Shīrāzī, Ṣadr al-Dīn Muḥammad (1981). Al-Hikama al-Muttaliyyah in Al-Asfar Al-Aqliyyah Al-Fourth (Vol. 9) (3rd edition). Beirut: Dar Ehiya al-Trath al-Arabi.
Al-Ṭabrisī, Aḥmad ibn ʿAlī (1381). Al-iḥtijāj ʿalā ahl al-lajāj (Behrad Jafari, translator) (1st edition). Tehran: Islamia.
Al-Rāzī, Qutb al-dīn, Muhammad bin Muhammad (1381). Ilahiyat Man al-Hamakamat between Sharahi al-Isharat (Majid Hadizadeh, scholar and proofreader). Tehran: Written Heritage Publishing Center.
Capleston, Frederick Charles (2008). History of Philosophy (Volume 1. Greece and Rome) (Seyd Jalaluddin Mojtaboi, translator). Tehran: Scientific and Cultural.
Tusi, Nasir al-dīn, Muhammad bin Muhammad (1375). Sharh al-Isharat (Commentary on Avicenna's Isharat) (Qutb al-din Razi, annotator) (Volume 3) (Print 1). Qom: Nash al-Balagha.
Avecinnian Philosophy Journal
Volume 26, Issue 68
October 2022
Pages 245-267

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics